Directed by Yôji Yamada. Written by Shûhei Fujisawa
(novels), Yôji Yamada (screenplay), and Yoshitaka Asama (screenplay). Starring
Hiroyuki Sanada (Seibei Iguchi), Rie Miyazawa (Tomeo Iinuma), and Nenji
Kobayashi (Choubei Kusaka).
Bottom line: If I were to pick two words to describe The Twilight Samurai, they would be
“taste” and “moderation” which are two very good words in my book.
3.5/4
Sheesh, it’s been a while since my last review. For that, I
apologize. I might be getting a new computer so I’ll be able to make a video
review more easily (not to suggest my tardiness is a result of anything but
me). Any-who, onto The Twilight Samurai!
The Twilight Samurai is
a story, set at the turn of the century, about a petty samurai father, Seibei
(Sanada), narrated by his then five-year-old daughter. Seibei’s wife died of
consumption leaving him to care for his dementia stricken mother, and two
daughters. Seibei is of the samurai class though he works as a bureaucrat in
the castle stores for a meager salary. IMDB summarizes the film as, “A
19th-century samurai tries to protect a battered wife.” This is only a minor plot
point in the film. We follow him as he experiences tests of character with
regard to his desires, his aspirations, and his duties to the clan.
Now, this may be an embarrassing testament to my general
ignorance of international movies but I mistook this for another film. There is
a popular samurai series about Zatoichi (aka “The Blind Swordsman”) that
follows the adventures of, as you can probably guess, a wandering Samurai who
is blind. According to
Wikipedia, a total of 26 films were made in the ‘60’s featuring this
character. I thought that The Twilight
Samurai was that. Clearly, any samurai movie is an action movie, right?
Sigh, it sounds even more embarrassing when I write it. In my defense, the film
The Blind Swordsman: Zatoichi came out in 2003. The Twilight Samurai is,
in fact, a serious and really good drama. It won just about every Japanese film
award possible and it’s not too surprising.
The acting is fabulous, the cinematography is beautiful, and
the music and sound are just as good. I’m generally not a fan of narration.
“Show me, don’t tell,” I think when I hear a narrator but I’ve certainly heard
worse narration than that of The Twilight
Samurai’s. I’m also generally not a fan of children in movies (read: I
generally loathe them in movies) but Seibei’s
daughters are adorable. They play a large part in the motivations of Seibei but
they don’t play a large part in the movie. They are there just enough to work
their way into your heart and make you sympathize with Seibei; one can
understand why he wants to stay at home, take care of them, and watch them grow.
Overall, The Twilight
Samurai is a very good movie. To my chagrin, I went in expecting a hack and
slash but was enthralled by the story presented in front of me. It’s happy and
sad at the same time, and despite being a very Japanese movie, as an American,
I found it accessible. By accessible, I mean that some movies use specific of
cultural cues that either go over my head or don’t jive with my American state
of mind. I’ll get more into detail about what I mean but it requires giving
away some spoilers. This all said, I’d recommend The Twilight Samurai to someone interested in watching a more
serious movie about the self and society and family. The only reason why I
didn’t give it a four out of four is because of some details surrounding the
ending (which I will discuss next). Now, mind yourself of spoilers from here on
out.
I mentioned that The
Twilight Samurai was a very Japanese movie. In my experiences with Japanese
movies, there are some recurring themes, namely, responsibility to one’s duty
particularly with respect to community versus the self. In The Twilight Samurai, we see this through Seibei and his
interactions with his clan.
A friend of Seibei comes back from Edo (the capital city which
was later renamed Tokyo) and offers to take him there for a promotion. Seibei
respectfully declines saying that his dream is to eventually give up the title
of Samurai and become a farmer with his daughters; he doesn’t want to rise up in
class because he’s happy and content. Despite this desire to become a farmer,
he is tasked with the job of killing a criminal samurai. The criminal was
ordered to commit suicide but didn’t, saying, “If you want me dead, you’ll have
to do it yourself.” The criminal samurai is the best one-sword fighter in the
clan so it’s a high-risk task. Seibei attempts to defer the “honor” or
responsibility to someone else but, eventually, accepts because it’s his duty
to follow the orders of the clan. The film doesn’t stop at the “following
orders” image. He accepts the task but reveals that he was going to let the criminal samurai escape to the mountains.
A while ago, I reviewed The Shonen Merikansak. It’s a movie about a washed-up punk band that reunites. The
movie seemed say, “Yeah, I wanna rock, so let’s rock.” The last shot of the
movie, however, undermines that whole message. It changes to “Yeah, I wanna
rock, but let’s be serious and get back to work after this bit of fun.” The Twilight Samurai contains the theme
of duty but still gives Seibei the strength to balance responsibility to one’s
post with responsibility to one’s moral code. Seibei explains that he intended
on letting the criminal escape to the mountains.
Unfortunately, the film takes an easy way out. After all,
what would happen if he let the guy escape? What type of repercussions would he
face? If he said that he let the guy go, Seibei would totally be executed. Well,
we don’t have to worry about it because the criminal samurai says, “I will
escape…after I kill you.” Conveniently, Seibei must defend himself and is thus
rewarded with money, and his dream wife. Is it a deal breaker? No, it reminds
me of my reaction to The Dead Poet Society.
Again, I’m sorry, for the hiatus from writing. I’ll try to
get into more of a rhythm; I’ve seen a bunch of movies recently, I’ve just not
made the time to write about them. But, in any case, what do you think? I’m
willing to bet that you’ve seen or are going to see the new Star Wars movie. I haven’t had the
chance to but I hope to soon. If I don’t write again in the next couple days, I
hope you had a Merry Christmas and have a happy New Year! Thanks for reading – I
really appreciate it!
